Gavros
9:48 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
|
Basically any film that doesn't show the English in a great light and worldbeaters is a load of old bollocks.
|
bruuuno
9:46 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
|
Is it worth a watch mad dog?
|
ironsofcanada
9:46 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
|
bruuuno 9:40 Sun Nov 16
Go watch a documentary then.
I bet the families and comrades of those soldiers depicted didn't feel a thing when they died so some effort to convey emotion is complete uncalled for.
Please. Give up the hard man act and have a good night.
|
Mad Dog
9:45 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
|
Superman 2
If you fall over the barriers at niagra falls, you would not fall for 19 seconds before hitting the water.
It's on c5 now. I counted. Yes I'm sad
|
bruuuno
9:40 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
|
Ok, I'd get rid of the scenes that show people getting killed in slow motion to the sound of sad music, you mountie fucking cretin
|
Far Cough
9:39 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
|
It certainly was true for Pearl Harbor
|
ironsofcanada
9:38 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
|
cuzoftheeast 9:34 Sun Nov 16
Great another one.
|
cuzoftheeast
9:34 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
|
Americans won the Second World War
Every US war film
|
ironsofcanada
9:33 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
|
bruuuno 9:29 Sun Nov 16
We discuss opinions here, son, if you don't want yours discussed, don't post it.
It is basically a true story, you said it was too sentimental, I was honestly curiously how you would change the telling of it to make it better for you.
You can call me names and avoid the question but that is all that was going on.
|
bruuuno
9:29 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
|
Or I could just have an opinion on something without you having to over analyse it, you semi autistic twat
|
ironsofcanada
9:27 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
|
bruuuno 9:25 Sun Nov 16
If you are going to make a statement that something is wrong, have the guts to explain how you would fix it. Or you could play around with words.
|
bruuuno
9:25 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
|
ironsofcanada 8:50 Sun Nov 16
??
|
MrCrowmanSir
8:59 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
|
Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade.
|
Eggbert Nobacon
8:50 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
|
No that was peace loving nelson Mandela snes
|
Me_And_My_Monkey
8:50 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
|
Jajaja,
More or less!
Ridikzappa 3:13 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
Mel Gibson's The Patriot:
British troops burning down a church with civilians locked inside.
Never happened and a disgraceful twist of history as the only known case was actually the Nazis in occupied France
|
ironsofcanada
8:50 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
|
bruuuno 8:44 Sun Nov 16
Good try.
|
Ridikzappa
8:46 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
|
Me_And_My_Monkey wrote...
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
Ridikzappa 3:13 Sun Nov 16
Re
Didn't Boudicca's tribe do that to the Romans in Colchester?
What, set fire to car tyres filled with petrol, around peoples' necks?
|
bruuuno
8:44 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
|
ironsofcanada 8:11 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
I would make it the same, so that it appeals to lots of people and makes me a lot of money
|
Mad Dog
8:28 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
|
Essex boys. I can't and shan't accept
1. Arcades and nightclubs on both sides of southend seafront
2. Going over Dartford Bridge to get to southend
3. Lakeside being just off southend seafront
|
ironsofcanada
8:24 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
|
Son of Anarchy 8:10 Sun Nov 16
You said everything American about WWII which includes it, unless you want to wiggle out of it by saying its a not a film, though it was based on a book.
If you want to go by the letter of the law -
Thin Red Line
The Big Red One
Letters from Iwo Jima
are not terrible! films - in terms of accuracy
|
Son of Anarchy
8:23 Sun Nov 16
Re: What's the most ridiculous historical inaccuracy you've ever picked up on in a film or book?
|
Monument Men is about as realistic return of the jedi
|
| 
